Sustaining life in hazardous environments...
Sustaining life in hazardous environments...

Breathing Apparatus – Escape, Self-Contained and Airline – What Are The Differences?

4th July 2016
Breathing Apparatus – Escape, Self-Contained and Airline – What Are The Differences?

So many times people will refer to the need for ‘BA’ or ‘Breathing Apparatus’ without making any distinction as to which type is needed or somebody will just make a vague reference to an entry that requires breathing apparatus.

It might just be a safety advisor who said that you should consider the use of ‘BA’. In many cases you may be left wondering – well great, but what type of Breathing Apparatus? This article will help you clarify the most appropriate type for each situation.

First, it’s good to consider why we use breathing apparatus. Breathing Apparatus, or supplied air as it is sometimes known as, is used where the atmosphere is not suitable to be breathed. Mainly it is used where a filter mask or powered air filter system is not suitable, but sometimes other factors are involved.

There are 3 main types of Breathing Apparatus – Escape, Self-Contained and Airline.

Escape Breathing Apparatus Escape Breathing Apparatus

Escape Breathing Apparatus is used for self-rescue from an environment that has become hazardous after entry into it. The most common example of this in-use is in a confined space where there is no immediate danger from gas or oxygen deficiency but the risk of that danger remains, and so an Escape BA set is carried enabling the user to don the set and rescue themselves from a hazardous environment. An Escape Set consists of a small compressed air cylinder, either 2.0L or 3.0L in size, that feeds air into a face piece. Escape Sets are usually supplied with either a positive pressure close-fitting face mask or with a loose fitting hood. Regular users of full face masks will usually prefer the comfort and familiarity of a close-fitting face mask, whilst irregular users will find the loose fitting hood easier to don in an emergency situation. It is worth noting as well that a loose fitting hood accommodates users with facial hair and glasses.

 

Self- Contained Breathing ApparatusSelf Contained Breathing Apparatus

Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) or Compressed Air Breathing Apparatus (CABA) is used for entry into a known hazardous environment. One user we will all recognise is the Fire Services, who use SCBA to enter areas where smoke and noxious gases are present, but SCBA is used in many entries where there is a toxic gas, asphyxiate or oxygen deficient environment. A SCBA set consists of 3 main components – a cylinder of compressed air, a back-plate that holds the cylinder and reduces the air from high pressure (200-300bar) to medium pressure (5-11 bar) and this in turn supplies a face mask. Self-Contained BA gives autonomy to the user, meaning that they can move around freely as opposed to being attached to an airline. However, the disadvantages are that the cylinder has a relatively short supply time, for example a 9.0L 200 bar cylinder giving a usage time of 35 minutes, and also the cylinder means an increased size and therefore can hinder ease of movement through tight spaces. There are many different sizes of cylinders which can improve duration or manoeuvrability, but these limitations will still remain to some extent.

 

 
Airline Breathing Apparatus Airline Breathing Apparatus

Airline Breathing Apparatus is where the air supply is removed from the user and they are fed compressed air via an airline. The compressed air source should deliver them air that has been air quality tested to EN12021, and may be supplied from a cylinder bank or breathing air compressor, which may be either fixed or mobile. The airline supplies the user's face mask through an airline harness. An airline system often incorporates an escape cylinder which the user wears to ensure that in the event of the main air supply failing they have a short duration air supply to allow to self-rescue themselves safely. Airline systems are used where the work is relatively localised and likely to be for longer durations. The main disadvantage of being attached to an airline is that it restricts easy movement, and poses a risk of entanglement. However, by being attached to an airline the user can work for as long as is comfortable and safe for them in the environment they are in without the requirement to refill or change a cylinder. A very good example of where an airline system is relevant is tank cleaning. A large tank may take several days or even weeks to thoroughly clean, so an airline breathing apparatus may be required in this one area for long durations. Particular attention should be paid to selecting a suitable air supply source for the work site and the table below gives a quick start guide.

 

System Advantages Disatvantages Typical Use
Fixed Compressor System – in areas where breathing air is required regularly
  • Installed and ready to use
  • Normally very capable systems
  • Costly to maintain
  • Lack of mobility
Factories or Spray Shops using supplied air regularly
Mobile Cylinder Bank or Trailer
  • Known air quality
  • Mobile
  • Require re-filling
  • Large units are very heavy
Petro-chem sites, and anywhere there is a significant risk of sudden pollution to the air
Mobile Breathing Air Compressor
  • Mobile
  • Smaller and lighter than air trailers
  • Only require refuelling
  • If air quality changes suddenly this could contaminate users
Tank cleaning, shot blasting, culvert cleaning – any other long duration entries 

 

The lists and definitions above are by no means definitive and are designed to give those using breathing apparatus a head start in the right direction. If you have any questions at all regarding the use of breathing apparatus, please do get in touch 0844 915 1111 or sales@breathesafety.com

 

Follow us on our social media to be the first to know when the new blog posts come out.

LinkedInFacebookTwitter

Back
This site uses some unobtrusive cookies to store information on your computer. By using our site you accept our Terms And Conditions and Privacy Policy. ×